Get faster access to personal & commercial Markets and appointments. Sign Up Now

First Acceptance Insurance Reviews

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Pros
    Affordable for high-risk drivers
  • Pros
    Offers SR-22 filing support
  • Pros
    Quick and easy online quote system
  • Pros
    Flexible payment plans

Cons

  • Cons
    Not available in all states
  • Cons
    Mixed reviews on customer service
  • Cons
    Limited coverage options
FeatureFirst AcceptanceGEICOThe GeneralProgressive
PricingCompetitive for high-risk driversAffordable for low-risk drivers Budget-friendly for high-risk drivers Competitive for a wide range of drivers
Coverage OptionsBasic coverage with limited customization Extensive add-ons and options Standard coverage tailored for non-standard drivers Highly customizable with a wide variety of options
Availability Only in 17 states Available in all 50 states and D.C. Available in 47 states Available nationwide
Financial Strength B rating from A.M. Best Backed by Berkshire Hathaway, strong financial stability Backed by Sentry Insurance, stable N/A

What do real customers have to say about their experience with First Acceptance Insurance?

3

(4 Reviews)
5
(2)
4
(0)
3
(0)
2
(0)
1
(2)
Reviews

Cynthia Moarr

This is my first time with the company, and so far, it’s been smooth getting a quote and completing paperwork online was quick and easy. The rate was reasonable too. Just wish they had an app for faster payments.

Joey Franks

I just bought another car and added 2 more drivers. Customer Service rep “Katrina” was helpful. Very professional, courteous and pleasant to speak with. Excellent job Ms. Katrina! I have been a customer with Acceptance since around 2015. Satisfied customer thus far.

Laubren Babin

If I could give zero stars, I would. They refused to fix a wrong-state policy or cancel it before activation—despite not servicing my state. No manager support, no refund, just poor customer service.

Derek D

Avoid this company at all costs. Poor service, no refund support, and hidden charges make it more trouble than it’s worth.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Is First Acceptance Insurance a reliable and trustworthy company?

    It has mixed reviews—some customers appreciate the affordable plans, while others report issues with claims handling.

  • Can I get insurance from First Acceptance with a poor driving record?

    Yes, they specialize in offering coverage to high-risk drivers, including those needing SR-22 filings.

  • What types of coverage does First Acceptance Insurance offer?

    They primarily offer auto insurance, including liability, collision, comprehensive, and SR-22 policies.

Author Display Picture
Carlos Ramirez

Updated on: June 18th, 2026

Carlos Ramirez is a licensed insurance agent with 12 years of experience helping clients protect their homes, vehicles, and businesses. Based in Colorado and licensed in 30+ states, he makes insurance simple and practical. His writing draws from real experience to help readers make clear, confident coverage decisions.