Get faster access to personal & commercial Markets and appointments. Sign Up Now

Heritage Insurance Review s

Yay or Nay in 2026?

Heritage Insurance Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Pros
    Homeowners in Florida can have more comprehensive coverage from this carrier 
  • Pros
    People of age 55 or above can take advantage of the senior or retiree discount.

Cons

  • Cons
    No online quote tool, which means no quick quotes
  • Cons
    Limited coverage available
  • Cons
    Costly rates
  • Cons
    No 24/7 customer support from the company
  • Cons
    Only available in five states in the USA
heritage insurance review infographic

Share This Infographic On Your Site

Save more by comparing quotes from multiple insurance agents near you.

secureEasy, free and secure.

Trusted agents working with top national companies.

farmers-insurance-1 allstate-1 geico-1 travellers-1 progressive-1 liberty-mutual-1 farmers-insurance-1 allstate-1 geico-1 travellers-1 progressive-1 liberty-mutual-1 farmers-insurance-1 allstate-1 geico-1 travellers-1 progressive-1 liberty-mutual-1 farmers-insurance-1 allstate-1 geico-1 travellers-1 progressive-1 liberty-mutual-1 farmers-insurance-1 allstate-1 geico-1 travellers-1 progressive-1 liberty-mutual-1 farmers-insurance-1 allstate-1 geico-1 travellers-1 progressive-1 liberty-mutual-1

Heritage Insurance Reviews and Ratings

4.3

(3 Reviews)
5
(2)
4
(0)
3
(1)
2
(0)
1
(0)
Reviews

“Loved the service from Heritage Insurance! I got a Heritage homeowners policy and have filed one claim after a hurricane hit Florida. They were really quick to respond to our concerns.”

“Very Good Insurance Company! They are very easy to work with. For my queries, they responded quickly and sent out the estimator right on time to look at the roof as soon as contacted.”

“I had a water leak about a month and a half ago, and I’ve written to the adjuster 22 times with no answer, left nine messages, and only spoken to my adjuster three times. I approached the supervisor, who promised to assist in moving things along, but I have yet to receive a response. Unfortunately, they said they can take 90 days to respond to a claim.”

OrganizationRatingDescription
DemotechAGood: This means Heritage has a good ability to pay back the claims even during challenging times 
BBBAExceptional: At least ninety-seven percent of all the insurers countrywide receive a Financial Stability Rating 
NAIC0.78This is lower than the industry average of 1.0, showing that Heritage Insurance's customer service is generally satisfactory. 

FAQ's

  • Is auto insurance available via Heritage Insurance?

    No, Heritage currently only provides insurance for homeowners, condos, and commercial properties in the Southeast and California.

  • Is Heritage Insurance limited to Florida residents?

    Heritage Insurance is not only offered in Alabama, California, Georgia, Mississippi, North Carolina, and South Carolina, but also in Alabama, California, Georgia, Mississippi, North Carolina, and South Carolina However, over 30% of Heritage Insurance policies are currently written in Florida.

  • What is the Heritage home insurance rating?

    Heritage has an A rating from the Better Business Bureau. Agency Height has given Heritage Insurance a rating of 2.4 out of 5 based on various factors, including coverage, availability, customer service, and more.

Author Display Picture
Agency Height Team

Updated on: June 18th, 2026

agent-icon
Compare Quotes from Top Local Agents

Explore, select, and save with agents who understand your unique needs.